FootballNewton, Tellbuescher, Overwhelm New Milford By Joe Hofmann November 17, 2026 Newton football coach Matt Parzero watched the New Milford game film, studied the stat sheet and … nah, it couldn’t be. But it was. Over and over … and over again … Braves linebacker Caulder Tellbuescher was in on a tackle. A New Milford run up the middle? There was Tellbuescher with the hit. Sweep? There he was. Counter? Yup, another Tellbuescher tackle. If it seemed as though the senior was all over the place, well … it’s because he was. Newton’s defense, led by Tellbuescher’s incredible night (18 tackles, 10 solos), sent New Milford’s All-Universe running back Kobe St. Hilaire packing. The Braves rolled to a resounding 40-7 victory to win the North 1, Group I championship, their second in school history and first since 2017. Newton (11-0) will travel to Cedar Grove in the state Group I semifinals Friday night. The winner will play the South Jersey survivor at MetLife Stadium on Thanksgiving weekend. Parzero’s team was able to extend its season by stopping the mighty St. Hilaire, who came up to Sussex County having already rushed for an astounding 2,540 yards and 30 touchdowns. He was indeed impressive at times and enjoyed a big night, finishing with 170 yards against Newton – but he needed 30 carries and his damage was minimal. For the first time this year, St. Hilaire did not score a touchdown. The Braves, meanwhile, rushed for 415 yards and four TDs in their 30 carries. And Newton QB Cole Young was perfect, completing all four of his passes for two more scores. It was a beautiful night to be a Brave – and much of it boiled down to Tellbuescher and Newton’s ironclad defense. In a showcase of two of the state’s top runners, Newton’s Evan Cotter (16 for 243, 3 TDs) prevailed over St. Hilaire. Cotter wasn’t alone, as Newton’s Braxton Guerra (7 for 96, 1 TD) and Reid Corino (5 for 71) took turns flying into the New Milford secondary. St. Hilaire did have some did-you-just-see-that runs, but he couldn’t keep pace. In his defense, he didn’t have the Newton defense to contend with. Early last week, Braves defensive coordinator Scott Zymut suggested that Newton switch from a four-man defensive front to a five-man in order to stuff St. Hilaire and the run-happy New Milford attack. That meant more time on the D-Line for the beefy duo of Joe Melillo and Tim McNamara and less snaps in the secondary for CB Noah Decker (even though he had two INTs in a state semifinal win against Kinnelon). True to form, Melillo and McNamara combined with Juzziah Sheppard, Nasen Cruz and Brayden Alpaugh (7 tackles, 1 for loss) to clog up the New Milford front wall. That freed up Tellbuescher, who took full advantage. “It was great,” he said. “I was locked in. A lot of fans were there. The lights were bright. I was ready to go.” Tellbuescher’s fellow linebackers – Cotter and Guerra – filled in some holes, as did the secondary (cornerbacks Decker and Corino, Wolfe brothers Chase and Hunter at safety). It was a team-effort, through and through. “We gang tackled,” Tellbuescher said. “All 11 should hit the kid at the same time. That was our thinking. Our goal was to make him have nowhere to go.” Right away, the Newton defense stepped up. New Milford gave the ball up on downs on its first two possessions. Early on, Tellbuescher had a tackle for loss on fourth-and-2 and Newton gained control of the ball. “That was a huge point in the game,” Parzero said. “He trusted his instincts. It’s nice when things we work on, like a pursuit drill, and the kids perform it during the game. The kids took proper angles and they bought in. We swarmed 5-6-7 guys to the ball, right up until the play was over. “We watched film of every game, and the kid (St. Hilaire) would break a tackle, and the other guys on the defense would kind of let up and assume he’d be tackled but he wasn’t and then he was gone. “You cannot assume he’ll be stopped.” During the season, Sheppard (69 tackles, 13 sacks, 25 tackles for loss, 5 forced fumbles, 2 fumble recoveries) and Alpaugh (47 tackles, 3 sacks, 15 TFLs, 2 forced fumbles, 2 recoveries) have been dominant. Against New Milford, it was Tellbuescher’s turn. He took a unique route to the New Milford game. Tellbuescher came out for football as an eighth-grader and envisioned himself as a quarterback. But in high school, he realized that QB wasn’t for him. He played some linebacker and some offensive guard. The summer going into his sophomore year, he was deadlifting with 315 pounds and developed Spondylolisthesis, which is a spinal condition where one vertebra slips out of position and rests on the vertebra below it. He felt the condition worsen during a summer wrestling tournament,so he sat out football during his sophomore year. He returned for wrestling that winter and played football last year. Parzero does the clock at Newton’s home wrestling matches and noticed Tellbuescher’s double-leg takedown and his physicality last winter. Parzero figured the kid would be an asset for the football team. Little did he know …. “Caulder is a great kid,” Parzero said. “I already knew him because we are a small school. I asked him last year, ‘Are you ready to come back?’ He said, ‘Absolutely.’ We had to tweak him and coach him, but the toughness he had I saw from wrestling helps.” The Newton offense, meanwhile, continued chugging along. The Braves Wing T has rushed for an incredible 3,763 yards, with Cotter (2,149 yards, 35 TDs), Corino (567 yards, 6 TDs) and Guerra (473 yards, 7 TDs) doing most of the damage. The first play of Newton’s night was Cotter rushing for 55 yards to set up Young’s 9-yard touchdown toss to Corino. Young would later connect with Wolfe for a 7-yard touchdown to make it 21-0 in the middle of the second quarter. “The first play of the game was our base belly play up the middle,” Parzero said. I know Cotter got 55 yards but we had such great downfield blocking from Hunter Wolfe and Braxton. I watched that play several times. Everyone threw key blocks and showed great hustle downfield. It is such a selfless group. At some schools, kids might not all buy in, but these kids are buying in and blocking for one another.”